New disclosure perspective additionally the standard concept of it verse is perhaps not, not, on the case of wedding so you can non-Muslims. This new classical interpretation says this verse is revealed whenever several polytheist men off Quraish required the sisters to be back, Oum Kelthoum and you may Bint Aqabah, once they had converted to Islam and moved to help you Medina inside the buy to become listed on the new Muslim area.
So it general tip isn’t necessarily genuine while the “strength” or even the “weakness” of your own spiritual trust is not associated with the gender but as an alternative into person’s identity and you will profile
It’s worth reminding that the Prophet finalized at the time a contract entitled Al-Hudaybya Pact toward reverse group off Quraish to eliminate the new conflict to have a decade. This agreement stipulated, among others, one to one Quraychit woman who join the Prophet in Medina without having any permission regarding her courtroom teacher will be delivered back to help you Mecca.
Oum Kelthoum, who was simply alone to transform to Islam within her family unit members, and just who fled in one of the very most intense environment, begged new Prophet to not ever repatriate her so you can their tribe so as the to not ever be unwrapped once again on the unjust cures.
The fresh verse aforementioned ended up being found to stop new extradition of women whom transformed into Islam and get away from the newest revenge of their particular families. For this reason, the fresh Prophet refused to post back brand new exiled ladies towards the foes, just like the arrangement are managed for males.
The explanation of one’s verse previously mentioned suggests that it does maybe not handle by any means the wedding so you’re able to non-Muslims, but was alternatively shown in order to meet http://datingreviewer.net/pl/brazilcupid-recenzja specific strategic criteria off protecting women who converted to Islam up against the tend to of their family members and you may who willingly asked for this new Prophet’s protection.
This new contradiction we emphasize within these traditional interpretations inquiries brand new fact that considering this type of scholars, Muslim women are banned so you’re able to get married “disbelievers” in addition to Christian and you may Jewish people, while toward matter of Muslim men, Religious and you may Jewish ladies are considered as believers. How do we think, in identical Religious otherwise Jewish community, one to men are disbelievers when you’re people of the identical communities are believers?
From the absence of people research you to justifies the newest ban off the marriage from Muslim people into the supporters out of almost every other monotheistic religions, brand new latest students justify the attitudes of the “the pure tiredness” out-of Muslim women who could go astray under the “bad” determine of its Religious otherwise Jewish husbands. But the Muslim guy may be able to dominate their Christian otherwise Jewish spouse and protect his child’s and you can very own faith.
The newest Qur’anic verse, tackling the wedding out of Muslim men or women so you’re able to believers out-of most other religions, lay some regulations having fun with a keen egalitarian code
Indeed, the fresh disagreement isn’t persuading because if the fresh new said verse forbids the wedding between a beneficial Muslim woman and you will good Christian or Jewish son because it’s unanimously translated now, very for example matrimony is also forbidden on the Muslim kid. Still, considering various Qur’anic verses and Islamic stability, Christians and you will Jews are believed unanimously since believers owned by religions revealed of the Allah whatever the current variations in terms of this new dogma and theological opinions.
Because of this, the research regarding the verse signifies that the new Qur’an prohibits the newest wedding out-of each other Muslim individuals polytheists.
But it’s well worth bringing-up that students agree unanimously into prohibition of the relationship out of good Muslim girl to help you an effective Jewish otherwise Religious, whenever you are zero part of the Qur’an offers eg prohibition one to warrants so it discrimination.